Note: Democratic ballots are the same across all municipalities, so only the ballot for Ayr Township is shown
| Ayr Township | Democratic | Republican |
| Belfast Township | Democratic | Republican |
| Bethel Township | Democratic | Republican |
| Brush Creek Township | Democratic | Republican |
| Dublin Township | Democratic | Republican |
| Licking Creek Township | Democratic | Republican |
| McConnellsburg Borough | Democratic | Republican |
| Taylor Township | Democratic | Republican |
| Thompson Township | Democratic | Republican |
| Todd Township | Democratic | Republican |
| Union Township | Democratic | Republican |
| Valley Hi Borough | Democratic | Republican |
| Wells Township | Democratic | Republican |